Published since September 1958

№ 4/2017

Ekon Ukr. 2017 (4): 22–45

ECONOMIC MANAGEMENT: THEORY AND PRACTICE

УДК 330.46:338.012:332.144

JEL:

¹National Institute for Strategic Studies, Research ID : http://www.researcherid.com/rid/
OrcID ID : https://orcid.org/https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3787-1323

LIGHT AND SHADOW OF THE ECONOMY OF UKRAINE: RESERVES FOR GROWTH AND MODERNIZATION

The article is devoted to interpreting the indicator of the shadow economy regarding its impact on official GDP and determination of internal and external shadow contributions of the official GDP at the level of country, main types of economic activity and regions. Analysis of advantages and disadvantages of existing methods for assessing the shadow economy was carried out; it is proved that it has both negative and positive traits. Unfortunately, existing methods of estimating the shadow GDP do not provide an answer to the questions: which part of GDP is created in addition to the official GDP and which part of GDP is created by shadow economic activity? Therefore, some experts suggest interpretation of indicator of the shadow economy, according to which the de-shadowing will not allow finding the significant additional economic resources, but will only contribute to their redistribution.
A method for evaluating the shadow economic activity (the "social justice method") is considered, which (i) provides answers to the questions raised, (ii) is a universal one, (iii) by functional possibilities surpasses all existing methods. A hypothesis has been proved about inverse relationship between share of wages in output and the level of shadowing the economy, what is the basis for determining the volumes of shadow GDP, shadow employment, shadow wages and other shadow indicators.
The proposed interpretation of indicator of the shadow economy states that there are two parts of the shadow GDP (GVA, GRP): the first, which is not considered by the State Statistics Service of Ukraine and is an addition to the official GDP due to an artificial increase in intermediate consumption; the second is created by the shadow wages through the consumption multiplier and is part of the official GDP. Therefore, it is necessary to struggle not with the shadow part of the official GDP, but with its external unaccounted part.
Thus, the correct redistribution of income between labor and capital will lead to a reduction in shadow incomes and increase in the level of wages in the output, wages, domestic consumption, investment and GDP. So, the shadow economy can be very important colossal reserve for economic recovery.

Keywords:shadow economy, interpretation of contribution to GDP, de-shadowing, country, type of economic activity, regions

Article original in Ukrainian (pp. 22 - 45)	Download	Downloads :143
Article original in Russian (pp. 22 - 45)	Download	Downloads :164

The article was received by the Editorial staff on January 24 , 2017

References
1. Global Risks Report 2011 Sixth Edition. An initiative of the Risk Response Network. Geneva, World Economic Forum, 2011, available at: reports.weforum.org/wp-content/blogs.dir/1/mp/uploads/pages/files/global-risks-2011.pdf.
2. Rozenfel’d A.I. Nevidoma Ukraina: dosvid ekspres-otsinky ekonomiky [Unknown Ukraine: experience of rapid assessment of the economy]. Dzerkalo Tyzhnya – Weeks’ Mirror, 2003, No. 14, available at: gazeta.dt.ua/ECONOMICS/nevidoma_ukrayina_dosvid_ekspres-otsinki_ekonomiki.html [in Ukrainian].
3. Prykhod’ko A. Posle shtorma: perspektivy ukrainskoi ekonomiki v 2017 godu [After the storm: the prospects for the Ukrainian economy in 2017], available at: finance.liga.net/economics/2016/12/28/opinion/51262.htm [in Russian].
4. Borodyuk V., Turchinov A., Prikhod’ko T. Otsenka masshtabov tenevoi ekonomiki i ee vliyanie na dinamiku makroekonomicheskikh pokazatelei [Estimation of the scales of a shadow economy and its influence on the dynamics of macroeconomic indices]. Ekonomika Ukrainy – Economy of Ukraine, 1996, No. 11, pp. 4–16 [in Russian].
5. Varnalii Z.S., Goncharuk A.Ya., Zhalilo Ya.A. et al. Tin’ova Ekonomika: Sutnist’, Osoblyvosti ta Shlyakhy Lehalizatsii [Shadow Economy: Essence, Features and Ways of Legalization]. Z.S.Varnalii (Ed.). Kyiv, NISS, 2006 [in Ukrainian].
6. Mazur I.I. Detinizatsiya Ekonomiky Ukrainy: Teoriya ta Praktyka [The De-shadowing of the Ukrainian Economy: Theory and Practice]. Kyiv, VPTs “Kyiv university”, 2006 [in Ukrainian].
7. Popovych V.M. Ekonomiko-Kryminolohichna Teoriya Detinizatsii Ekonomiky [Economic and Criminological Theory of De-shadowing the Economy]. Irpin’, Academy of the State Tax Service of Ukraine, 2001 [in Ukrainian].
8. Schneider F. The Shadow Economy and Work in the Shadow: What Do We (Not) Know? Institute for the Study of Labor, 2012, available at: ftp.iza.org/dp6423.pdf.
9. Ehrke Ju., Betliy O., Kirchner R., Giucci R. Propozytsii Shchodo Detinizatsii Ekonomiky Ukrainy [Proposals to De-shadow Ukraine’s Economy]. Berlin/Kyiv, Institute for Economic Research and Policy Consulting, German Advisory Group, 2011, available at: www.ier.com.ua/files/publications/Policy_papers/German_advisory_group/2011/PP_04_2011_ukr.pdf [in Ukrainian]
10. Bazylyuk A.V., Kovalenko S.O. Tin’ova Ekonomika v Ukraini [Shadow Economy in Ukraine]. Kyiv, SREI of the Ministry of Economy of Ukraine, 1998 [in Ukrainian].
11. Kharazishvili Yu.M. Teoretychni Osnovy Systemnoho Modelyuvannya Sotsial’no-Ekonomichnoho Rozvytku Ukrainy [The Theoretical Basis of System Modeling the Socio-Economic Development of Ukraine]. Kyiv, TOV “Poligraf-Konsalting”, 2007 [in Ukrainian].
12. Tyshchyuk T.A. Mif i real’nist’ pro riven’ tin’ovoi ekonomiky v Ukraini [Myth and reality about level of shadow economy in Ukraine], available at: ukr.segodnya.ua/economics/enews/mif-i-realnost-ob-urovne-tenevoy-ekonomiki-v-ukraine-673584.html [in Ukrainian].
13. Tyshchyuk T.A., Kharazishvili Yu.M., Ivanov O.V. et al. Tin’ova Ekonomika v Ukraini: Masshtaby ta Napryamky Podolannya [Shadow Economy in Ukraine: Scale and Directions of Overcoming: Analytical Report]. Ya.A. Zhalilo (Ed.). Kyiv, NISS, 2011 [in Ukrainian].
14. Kharazishvili Yu. Izmerenie tenevoho VVP na osnove funktsii sovokupnoho sprosa i sovokupnoho predlozheniya [The measurement of the shadow GDP on the basis of functions of the overall demand and the total offer]. Ekonomika Ukrainy – Economy of Ukraine, 2007, No. 1, pp. 57–63 [in Russian].
15. Kharazishvili Yu.M. Tin’ova zainyatist’ ta tin’ova oplata pratsi v Ukraini: otsinky ta prognozy [Shadow employment and shadow labor payment in Ukraine: estimates and forecasts]. Stratehiya rozvytku Ukrayiny. Ekonomika, sotsiolohiya, pravo – Development Ukraine. Economics, sociology, law, 2011, No. 4, Vol. 1, pp. 171–182 [in Ukrainian].
16. Mamalui O.O., Grytsenko O.A., Darnopykh G.Yu. et al. Osnovy Ekonomichnoi Teorii [Foundations of Economic Theory]. O.O. Mamalui (Ed.). Kyiv, Yurinkom Inter, 2005 [in Ukrainian].
17. Schneider F. Size and Development of the Shadow Economy of 31 European and 5 other OECD Countries from 2003 to 2013: A Further Decline, available at: www.econ.jku.at/members/Schneider/files/publications/2013/ShadEcEurope31_Jan2013. pdf.
18. Golubov A. Kuda ukhodyat den'gi [Where money goes to]. Korrespondent – Correspondent, 2012, No. 46 (534), pp. 16–20 [in Russian].
19. Kharazishvili Yu.M. Shchodo vyboru tochok vplyvu polityky stymulyuvannya ekonomichnoho zrostannya [To the choice of the points of influence of the policy of economic growth stimulating: analytical note]. Kyiv, NISS, 2011, available at: www.niss.gov.ua/articles/574/ [in Ukrainian].
20. Mel’ota I., Gregory P. Novyi Poglyad na Tin’ovu Ekonomiku Ukrainy: Chy Ii Vzhe Otsineno?, v: Naukovi Materialy № 11 [New Insights into Ukraine’s Shadow Economy: Has It Already been Counted?, in Working Paper No. 11]. Kyiv, Institute for Economic Research and Policy Consulting, 2011 [in Ukrainian].
21. Kharazishvili Yu.M., Koval’ O.P. Detinizatsiya zarobitnykh plat yak chynnyk sotsial’noho rozvytku ta zabezpechennya ekonomichnoi bezpeky Ukrainy [Deshadowing wages as a factor of the social development and provision of the economic security of Ukraine]. Stratehichni Prioritety – Strategic Priority Magazine, 2013, No. 4 (29), pp. 38–49 [in Ukrainian].
22. Kharazishvili Yu.M., Koval’ O.P., Novak I.M. Mozhlyvosti lehalizatsii zarobitnoi platy v Ukraini: pererozpodil sotsial’noi vidpovidal’nosti [The possibilities of legalization of wages in Ukraine: redistribution of social responsibility]. Demografiya ta sotsial’na ekonomika – Demography and social economy, 2013, No. 2 (20), pp. 191–200 [in Ukrainian].